BASS GODDESS
CAN EVERYONE CONCUR D'ARCY WILL BE BACK,FOR TEASE WHO ROCKS THE BASS PUMPKIN STYLE, D'ARCY, OR MELLISSA??

I think D'arcy was a better bassist, but Mellissa is still great, a lot hotter too, although there have been occaisions where D'arcy has looked SWEET! Richard xxx

well its pretty common knowledge that D'arcy is a terrible bassist, in over 10 years of the pumpkins she didnt seem to get any better but she was still mighty cool and had an amazing presense, on the other hand melissa is a pretty talented bassist, certainly better than d'arcy (although not the worlds top bassist by any stretch of the imagination), melissa is also cool, much mroe eneergettic melissa is the winner, easy oh and structure your sentences better...

I voted for d'arcy. Melissa has so much energy and she's a great bassist, but d'arcy is still the one and only pumpkins bass player to me. But you know, it's almost impossible that d'arcy will ever be in the new pumpkins. I don't think I'll be disappointed if the bassist turns out to be Melissa our someone else.

I voted for Melissa. She just has a better stage prescence and her energy works with the band. Yeah, the chances of D'arcy returning are slim to none.